FA Chief Opposes VAR Expansion: Balancing Accuracy and Game Flow

FA Chief Opposes VAR Expansion: Balancing Accuracy and Game Flow

Football Association (FA) chief executive Mark Bullingham has firmly stated that there is no need to extend the use of the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system. Bullingham believes that the current model already introduces enough interruptions to the game, and expanding VAR's scope could further disrupt the flow of play.

Current VAR Usage

VAR, introduced to the Premier League at the start of the 2019-2020 season, is currently limited to specific situations:

Goals
Penalty decisions
Direct red cards
Mistaken identity

Calls on free-kicks and corners remain the responsibility of on-field officials. There have been discussions within the International FA Board (Ifab) about potentially widening VAR's powers to include these areas, as well as second yellow cards.

FA's Stance

Bullingham emphasized the FA's position during a recent interview with BBC Sport:

"We don't think there's any need to extend the use of VAR. There are regular discussions in Ifab about what VAR should be, and how it should move forward. I think our position is that we're in a good place now."

He added that while the FA would consider any proposals brought forward, the general consensus is that VAR does not need to be extended at this time.

Concerns Over Game Interruptions

One of the primary concerns with expanding VAR is the potential for increased delays. FIFA's referees chief, Pierluigi Collina, acknowledged in 2023 that widening VAR's use would be considered, but stressed that it must not lead to more interruptions.

Recent Controversies

Last season, several incidents highlighted the limitations of VAR. For example, Leandro Trossard was sent off in Arsenal's 2-2 draw at Manchester City after receiving a second yellow card for kicking the ball away. Under current rules, VAR could not intervene, sparking debate over whether such decisions should be reviewable.

Fan Sentiment

A 2023 survey by the Football Supporters' Association found that almost two-thirds of fans opposed the use of VAR in English football. Complaints often centered around the length of delays and the poor in-stadium experience for fans.

Premier League's Response

The 2023-24 Premier League season ended with Wolves triggering a vote to scrap VAR, though clubs ultimately voted 19-1 in favour of keeping it. The Premier League has since committed to improving VAR by reducing delays and increasing transparency for fans.

Looking Ahead

Any potential changes to VAR's scope would require a three-quarters majority vote at Ifab's annual general meeting in March. With the FA and other key stakeholders opposing expansion, it seems unlikely that VAR's powers will be extended in the near future.

Related Topics: