Former Premier League manager Harry Redknapp stirred up controversy at a London charity event by joking that England national team manager Thomas Tuchel is a "German spy." The 78-year-old ex-Portsmouth, Tottenham, and West Ham boss even playfully mimicked a Nazi salute during his remarks, drawing laughter from the audience.

The Joke That Sparked Reactions

Redknapp’s comments, captured in a video clip obtained by The Guardian, suggested that Tuchel was sent to England to "ruin" the national team. He referenced Lord Haw-Haw, the infamous WWII Nazi propagandist, adding a satirical touch to his remarks. The joke quickly circulated online, dividing opinions among fans and media.

Mixed Public Reaction

While some social media users criticized Redknapp for the joke, others found it harmless. German comedian Henning Wehn, known for his appearances on BBC Radio 5 Live, dismissed the controversy, saying, "What a non-story. Lighten up! If we're not allowed a bit of banter, what's the point of football?"

Tuchel’s Rise with England

Tuchel, England’s third foreign permanent manager after Sven-Göran Eriksson and Fabio Capello, has had a strong start, securing wins against Albania and Latvia in World Cup qualifiers. Despite his German nationality, Tuchel has emphasized his commitment to England, stating last month, "I need to earn the right to sing the national anthem."

Redknapp’s Legacy vs. Tuchel’s Success

Redknapp remains the last English manager to win a major trophy (2008 FA Cup with Portsmouth) before Eddie Howe’s 2023 Carabao Cup triumph with Newcastle. Meanwhile, Tuchel, who previously guided Chelsea to Champions League glory, continues to build his reputation with the Three Lions.

The Fine Line Between Banter and Controversy

The incident reignites debates about humor in football culture. While some view Redknapp’s comments as lighthearted, others question whether historical references should be part of sports banter. Football’s mix of comedy and competition keeps fans engaged—but occasionally sparks controversy.