As the 2025 NFL season approaches, fantasy football managers are faced with a pivotal decision: Saquon Barkley or Ashton Jeanty? Both running backs bring unique strengths to the table, but who will deliver the most value for your fantasy team?

Saquon Barkley: The Proven Performer

Saquon Barkley, the Philadelphia Eagles' star, had a historic 2024 season, rushing for over 2,000 yards and leading all running backs with an average of 22.2 fantasy points per game. His ability to consistently perform at a high level makes him a tempting first-round pick. However, concerns about potential regression due to his high usage last season linger.

Ashton Jeanty: The Rising Star

On the other hand, Ashton Jeanty, the rookie from the Las Vegas Raiders, is drawing comparisons to legends like Steven Jackson and Emmitt Smith. Known for his ability to break tackles and his versatility, Jeanty could be a game-changer in the Raiders' revamped offense under Chip Kelly.

Comparative Analysis

Key Considerations

• Barkley's Volume: Barkley carried the ball 345 times last season, not including postseason play. History shows that high-volume backs often see a dip in efficiency the following year.
• Jeanty's Potential: As a rookie, Jeanty has fresh legs and could thrive in a stable offensive environment. His ability to force missed tackles (126 in FBS) makes him a promising pick.

Expert Opinions

Liz Loza favors Jeanty, citing Barkley's potential regression and the fresh opportunities Jeanty brings. Tyler Fulghum, however, believes in Barkley's proven track record and his ability to anchor a fantasy team to victory.

Conclusion

Choosing between Barkley and Jeanty is no easy task. While Barkley offers proven performance, Jeanty's potential for a breakout season is undeniable. Your decision will ultimately shape the fate of your fantasy football season.