Bill Barnwell: The greatest rookie seasons in NFL history, and why we might be watching No. 1

The Commanders quarterback had 31 touchdowns in the regular season and has already won two playoff games. How does he stack up vs. the best ever?

Jayden Daniels is one game away from going where no rookie quarterback has gone before. With a Commanders win over the Eagles on Sunday in the NFC Championship Game, he would become the first rookie passer in league history to lead his team to a Super Bowl. Beating Philadelphia for the second time in six weeks and advancing to the title game would be the latest in a series of stunning accomplishments. It would also raise a question I'm not sure even the most optimistic of Washington fans would have expected to ask after the 2024 season:Is Daniels having the best rookie season in NFL history?While his season isn't yet complete, it's possible to compare the No. 2 pick to other great rookies from the past, many of whom were already on vacation by the time the NFL got down to the final four teams in the playoff bracket. There's a significant element of subjectivity in deciding where he stands versus his peers from the past, but there are also a few objective measures of performance to use to gauge where he lands.Let's break all that down. I'll compare Daniels to great rookies from previous years, contextualize what has made this season so impressive and try to somehow decide where he ranks among the tens of thousands of other rookies in NFL history. All of that has to start somewhere, and I'll begin by comparing him to the best rookie quarterbacks ever.

What to Read Next

Pittsburgh Steelers Receivers Embrace 'Grimy' Mentality for NFL Success
NFL

Pittsburgh Steelers Receivers Embrace 'Grimy' Mentality for NFL Success

The Pittsburgh Steelers' wide receivers are adopting a 'grimy' mentality to excel in the NFL, emphasizing physicality and teamwork under new quarterback Aaron Rodgers.

Trevor Lawrence and Key Jaguars Players Poised for Breakout Seasons in 2025
NFL

Trevor Lawrence and Key Jaguars Players Poised for Breakout Seasons in 2025

Explore how Trevor Lawrence and other Jacksonville Jaguars players are gearing up for a pivotal 2025 NFL season under new head coach Liam Coen.

Falcons QB Dynamics: Cousins' Role and Penix's Rise in the 2025 NFL Season
NFL

Falcons QB Dynamics: Cousins' Role and Penix's Rise in the 2025 NFL Season

Explore how Kirk Cousins fits into the Atlanta Falcons' QB strategy and the impact on Michael Penix Jr.'s development as the team's new starter.

Kyle Hamilton's Romantic Proposal: Ravens' Star Safety Engages Longtime Girlfriend in France
NFL

Kyle Hamilton's Romantic Proposal: Ravens' Star Safety Engages Longtime Girlfriend in France

Baltimore Ravens safety Kyle Hamilton announces his engagement to longtime girlfriend Reese Damm in a romantic proposal in France.

How J.K. Dobbins and RJ Harvey Revolutionize the Broncos' Running Game Strategy
NFL

How J.K. Dobbins and RJ Harvey Revolutionize the Broncos' Running Game Strategy

Explore how J.K. Dobbins and rookie RJ Harvey are set to transform the Denver Broncos' running game under coach Sean Payton's strategic vision.

Miami Dolphins' Elite Pass-Rush Trio Poised to Dominate NFL Season
NFL

Miami Dolphins' Elite Pass-Rush Trio Poised to Dominate NFL Season

The Miami Dolphins' pass-rush trio of Bradley Chubb, Jaelan Phillips, and Chop Robinson is set to make a significant impact in the upcoming NFL season, bringing confidence and strength to the team's defense.

Toronto Blue Jays Take Hilarious Jab at Cleveland Browns' QB Dilemma Amid Guardians' Error
NFL

Toronto Blue Jays Take Hilarious Jab at Cleveland Browns' QB Dilemma Amid Guardians' Error

The Toronto Blue Jays trolled the Cleveland Browns after a Guardians' error, highlighting the Browns' ongoing quarterback struggles in a witty social media post.

NFL Offseason Final Moves: Key Signings, Trades, and Extensions for 2025 Season
NFL

NFL Offseason Final Moves: Key Signings, Trades, and Extensions for 2025 Season

Explore the final moves every NFL team should make this offseason, including key signings, trades, and contract extensions to strengthen rosters for the 2025 season.

Top 10 Underrated NFL Pass Catchers for Fantasy Football 2025
NFL

Top 10 Underrated NFL Pass Catchers for Fantasy Football 2025

Discover the top 10 underrated NFL pass catchers for the 2025 fantasy football season, featuring players with high upside and reliable floors.

NFC East 2025: Can the Eagles Defy History and Secure Back-to-Back Titles?
NFL

NFC East 2025: Can the Eagles Defy History and Secure Back-to-Back Titles?

Explore the NFC East's 2025 season as the Philadelphia Eagles aim to break a 20-year streak without a repeat champion. Can Jalen Hurts lead them to glory again?

Marvin Harrison Jr.'s Offseason Transformation: A Rising Star in the NFL
NFL

Marvin Harrison Jr.'s Offseason Transformation: A Rising Star in the NFL

Marvin Harrison Jr. showcases significant offseason growth, earning praise from teammates and coaches as he prepares for a standout second season with the Arizona Cardinals.

The Wilfs' Legacy: Building a Championship Culture with the Minnesota Vikings
NFL

The Wilfs' Legacy: Building a Championship Culture with the Minnesota Vikings

Explore the Wilf family's 20-year journey as owners of the Minnesota Vikings, their commitment to excellence, and their ultimate goal of winning a Super Bowl.

Taylor Swift and Kane Brown Stun Fans with Surprise Performance at Tight End University 2025
NFL

Taylor Swift and Kane Brown Stun Fans with Surprise Performance at Tight End University 2025

Taylor Swift and Kane Brown deliver a surprise performance at Tight End University 2025, celebrating NFL's top tight ends with a live rendition of 'Shake It Off'.

Aaron Rodgers' Retirement Plan: A Strategic Advantage for the Pittsburgh Steelers
NFL

Aaron Rodgers' Retirement Plan: A Strategic Advantage for the Pittsburgh Steelers

Aaron Rodgers' announcement of his likely retirement after the 2025 season provides the Pittsburgh Steelers with a strategic edge in planning their future quarterback position.

Saints Wide Receivers: Bonding Through Nicknames and Building a Stronger 2025 Season
NFL

Saints Wide Receivers: Bonding Through Nicknames and Building a Stronger 2025 Season

Discover how the New Orleans Saints wide receivers are bonding through unique nicknames and preparing for a stronger 2025 NFL season after a challenging 2024.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.