7 Underdog Teams Poised to Shake Up the 2025 College Football Playoff

Discover the seven underdog teams that could make a surprising run to the 2025 College Football Playoff, following in the footsteps of Indiana's historic rise.

The 2024 college football season was marked by unexpected twists and turns, with the Indiana Hoosiers emerging as the most surprising contender in the College Football Playoff (CFP). As we look ahead to the 2025 season, several teams are poised to replicate Indiana's success and potentially disrupt the CFP landscape. Here’s a closer look at seven underdog programs that could make a significant leap:

Illinois Fighting Illini

  • 2024 Record: 10-3
  • Case for 2025: Illinois is coming off its first 10-win season since 2001 and has retained key players like quarterback Luke Altmyer and defensive standout Gabe Jacas. With a strong roster and strategic transfer additions, the Illini are well-positioned to contend for a CFP spot.

Texas Tech Red Raiders

  • 2024 Record: 8-5
  • Case for 2025: Texas Tech has made significant investments in its program, including a top-tier transfer class. With a focus on strengthening the offensive and defensive lines, the Red Raiders could make a historic run in 2025.

Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets

  • 2024 Record: 7-6
  • Case for 2025: Under coach Brent Key, Georgia Tech has shown it can compete with top-tier teams. With quarterback Haynes King returning and a strong recruiting class, the Yellow Jackets could be a dark horse in the ACC.

South Carolina Gamecocks

  • 2024 Record: 9-4
  • Case for 2025: South Carolina has closed the talent gap in the SEC and returns a young, dynamic quarterback in LaNorris Sellers. With key transfers bolstering the defense, the Gamecocks could make a push for the CFP.

Iowa State Cyclones

  • 2024 Record: 11-3
  • Case for 2025: Iowa State has been a consistent performer in the Big 12 and returns a strong core of players, including quarterback Rocco Becht. The Cyclones could finally break through and secure a CFP berth.

Colorado Buffaloes

  • 2024 Record: 9-4
  • Case for 2025: Under Deion Sanders, Colorado has quickly risen to prominence. With a focus on improving line-of-scrimmage play and a talented transfer class, the Buffaloes could make a deep playoff run.

North Carolina Tar Heels

  • 2024 Record: 6-7
  • Case for 2025: The hiring of Bill Belichick has brought renewed optimism to North Carolina. With a focus on rebuilding the defense and developing young talent, the Tar Heels could surprise many in 2025.

These seven teams have the potential to follow in Indiana's footsteps and make a historic run to the College Football Playoff in 2025. Keep an eye on these underdogs as they aim to shake up the college football landscape.

What to Read Next

CFB 26 Unveils Enhanced Gameplay Features and Mascot Additions
NCAAF

CFB 26 Unveils Enhanced Gameplay Features and Mascot Additions

Discover the latest updates in College Football 26, including new mascots, dynamic runouts, and enhanced gameplay features.

EA Sports Unveils Game-Changing Features in College Football 26: A Deep Dive into Dynamic Substitutions and Wear & Tear System
NCAAF

EA Sports Unveils Game-Changing Features in College Football 26: A Deep Dive into Dynamic Substitutions and Wear & Tear System

Explore the latest enhancements in College Football 26, including dynamic substitutions and a detailed wear & tear system, designed to elevate gameplay realism.

Big Sky Conference Welcomes Southern Utah and Utah Tech for 2026-27 Season
NCAAF

Big Sky Conference Welcomes Southern Utah and Utah Tech for 2026-27 Season

Southern Utah and Utah Tech are set to join the Big Sky Conference as full members starting in the 2026-27 academic year, enhancing the league's stability and success.

Bryce Steele's Inspiring Comeback: From Cancer Survivor to College Football Star
NCAAF

Bryce Steele's Inspiring Comeback: From Cancer Survivor to College Football Star

Discover how Bryce Steele battled cancer and made a triumphant return to football with Boston College, inspiring fans and teammates alike.

Auburn's Marching Band Sets the Tone for College Football 26: A Symphony of Sports and Technology
NCAAF

Auburn's Marching Band Sets the Tone for College Football 26: A Symphony of Sports and Technology

Auburn University's marching band has been chosen to record the main theme for College Football 26, inspired by their Metallica-themed halftime show.

2025 AAC Football Preview: Army and Navy Set to Shake Up the Conference Again
NCAAF

2025 AAC Football Preview: Army and Navy Set to Shake Up the Conference Again

Get the latest insights on the 2025 AAC football season, featuring Army and Navy's impact, key matchups, and championship contenders.

2026 NCAAF Recruiting Insights: Elite 11 Finals and Official Visits Shaping the Future
NCAAF

2026 NCAAF Recruiting Insights: Elite 11 Finals and Official Visits Shaping the Future

Discover the latest updates from the Elite 11 Finals and final official visits shaping the 2026 NCAAF recruiting class.

2025 NCAAF Season Preview: Key Players, Teams, and Conference Breakdowns
NCAAF

2025 NCAAF Season Preview: Key Players, Teams, and Conference Breakdowns

Get ready for the 2025 NCAAF season with in-depth previews of key players, teams, and conferences. Bill Connelly breaks down the top prospects and projections.

2025 Sun Belt Conference Football Preview: James Madison Aims for Redemption
NCAAF

2025 Sun Belt Conference Football Preview: James Madison Aims for Redemption

A comprehensive preview of the 2025 Sun Belt Conference football season, focusing on James Madison's quest for redemption and the competitive landscape of the league.

JaReylan McCoy Commits to Florida Gators: A Game-Changing Addition to the 2026 Recruiting Class
NCAAF

JaReylan McCoy Commits to Florida Gators: A Game-Changing Addition to the 2026 Recruiting Class

Five-star defensive end JaReylan McCoy commits to the Florida Gators, solidifying their 2026 recruiting class with a top-ranked prospect.

Top 10 Under-the-Radar Prospects for the 2026 NFL Draft: Who Could Rise Quickly?
NCAAF

Top 10 Under-the-Radar Prospects for the 2026 NFL Draft: Who Could Rise Quickly?

Discover the top 10 under-the-radar prospects for the 2026 NFL Draft as identified by NFL scouts. These players could rise quickly in the draft rankings.

2025-2026 NCAAF Future Power Rankings: Top 68 Teams Analyzed
NCAAF

2025-2026 NCAAF Future Power Rankings: Top 68 Teams Analyzed

Comprehensive analysis of the top 68 NCAAF teams for the 2025 and 2026 seasons, focusing on rosters, recruiting, and transfer portal impacts.

Top 25 Unforgettable NCAAF Plays Since 2000: A Journey Through College Football's Greatest Moments
NCAAF

Top 25 Unforgettable NCAAF Plays Since 2000: A Journey Through College Football's Greatest Moments

Relive the most iconic and thrilling plays in NCAAF history since 2000, as voted by ESPN writers, capturing the essence of college football's greatest moments.

NCAAF Leaders Optimistic About NIL Rule Enforcement Post-Settlement
NCAAF

NCAAF Leaders Optimistic About NIL Rule Enforcement Post-Settlement

NCAAF conference commissioners express confidence in enforcing NIL rules following a landmark legal settlement, aiming for stability and fairness in college sports.

Tyson Helton's Quest for Quarterback Excellence: Building Western Kentucky's Football Legacy
NCAAF

Tyson Helton's Quest for Quarterback Excellence: Building Western Kentucky's Football Legacy

Discover how Tyson Helton's strategic approach to quarterback recruitment is shaping Western Kentucky's success in NCAAF, defying odds in a competitive landscape.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.